Start from what was agreed
A review measures the period against what was agreed at its start: the objectives, the KPIs and their weights, the competencies the role needs. If none of that was agreed, say so in the review, rate what can be measured, and agree it properly for the next period.
Open the KPI sheet and the objectives before you write a word. The review is a report on them, not a fresh opinion.
Evidence before adjectives
"Excellent communicator" tells the reader what you think. "Ran the weekly client update for the full year, and the client renewed" tells them why. Lead with the second; the adjective is optional.
Good evidence is specific, dated and checkable: a result against a KPI, a piece of work, a piece of feedback, a document. Collect it during the year; a review written from memory in December is a review of November.
Results and behaviour are different questions
KPIs and objectives answer what was achieved. Competencies answer how. Keep them apart: a missed target caused by a supplier is not a teamwork problem, and a met target reached by overriding colleagues is not a clean success.
Rate each competency against the level the role needs, next to the behaviour you observed.
Performance review phrases that hold up
Write each comment so that it would survive the question "how do you know?". A few rewrites:
- Instead of "Needs to improve time management", write "Three of five reports this quarter were submitted after the agreed date".
- Instead of "Great team player", write "Covered the onboarding of two new colleagues in March while delivering her own targets".
- Instead of "Not proactive", write "Raised the budget risk after it had been reported by finance; we agreed she flags risks at the weekly meeting".
- Instead of "Excellent quality of work", write "Four of five releases passed review first time, against a target of three".
- Instead of "Good communicator", write "Wrote the monthly status note for the steering committee; it drew no follow-up questions in the last two months".
Describe the work, not the person, and avoid words that compare the employee with colleagues by name.
Rate with the band definitions
Use the meaning of each band, not a feeling about the person. If the scale says Proficient means "fully meets expectations", ask whether the evidence shows that, and rate accordingly. Most people in most years are Proficient; that is the band working, not a failure.
If you are tempted to rate higher to motivate or lower to send a message, write the motivation or the message in the comments instead. Calibration will compare your ratings with other managers', so ratings that drift will be questioned there.
The conversation
Share the written review before the meeting, so the employee comes prepared rather than surprised. In the meeting, go through the evidence first and the rating last, listen to anything the employee disagrees with, and record it in their comments section.
End with the development plan: one or two goals, the actions, the support you will give and a date.
A short checklist
- Each rating points to evidence.
- Results and behaviour are rated separately.
- Comments describe the work, not the person.
- The band definitions decide the rating.
- The employee saw the review before the meeting.
- Disagreements are recorded.
- The development plan has dates.